Best Pet Insurance Plans 2026
We compared 12 pet insurance providers on coverage, exclusions, reimbursement rates, and real claims data. Here are the five that offer the best value for dogs and cats.
Healthy Paws
Best overallMonthly cost
$25–$55
Reimbursement
70%, 80%, or 90%
Deductible
$100–$500/yr
Wait period
15 days illness / 2 days accidents
Pros
- Unlimited lifetime benefits
- Fast claims (avg 2 days)
- No per-incident caps
Cons
- No wellness add-on
- Premium rises with age
Trupanion
Best for direct vet paymentMonthly cost
$30–$100
Reimbursement
90% (fixed)
Deductible
Per-condition deductible
Wait period
30 days illness / 5 days accidents
Pros
- Pays vet directly at checkout
- 90% reimbursement, no payout cap
- Covers hereditary conditions
Cons
- No annual deductible option
- Higher monthly cost
Lemonade
Best for low monthly costMonthly cost
$15–$50
Reimbursement
70%, 80%, or 90%
Deductible
$100–$500/yr
Wait period
14 days illness / 2 days accidents
Pros
- Lowest starting price
- Instant claim decisions via app
- Wellness add-on available
Cons
- Annual limits ($5K–$100K)
- App-only experience may not suit all
Embrace
Best loyalty perksMonthly cost
$25–$65
Reimbursement
70%, 80%, or 90%
Deductible
$200–$1000/yr (shrinks $50/yr claim-free)
Wait period
14 days illness / 2 days accidents
Pros
- Diminishing deductible reward
- Flexible annual limits
- Covers alternative therapies
Cons
- Annual limit ($5K–$30K)
- Dental illness limited
Figo
Best for 100% reimbursementMonthly cost
$20–$55
Reimbursement
70%, 80%, 90%, or 100%
Deductible
$100–$750/yr
Wait period
14 days illness / 1 day accidents
Pros
- 100% reimbursement option available
- 1-day accident wait period
- Cloud-based pet records
Cons
- Premium can be high at 100% tier
- Smaller company
What to look for in a pet insurance plan
Reimbursement rate
The percentage the insurer pays after your deductible. 90% is the sweet spot — you pay 10% of covered vet bills. Some providers cap at 80%. A few (Figo) offer 100% but at significantly higher premium.
Annual vs. per-condition deductible
Annual deductibles reset once per year — better if your pet has multiple issues. Per-condition deductibles (Trupanion's model) reset each time a new condition arises, which can cost more if your pet has several problems.
Annual vs. unlimited payouts
Unlimited plans (Healthy Paws, Trupanion) have no cap on how much they'll pay per year. Annual-limit plans ($5K–$100K) are cheaper but can leave you exposed if your pet has a serious illness like cancer, which often costs $10K–$20K.
Waiting periods
Most plans have 14–30 day waits for illness coverage and 2–5 days for accidents. Pre-existing conditions detected or treated before or during the waiting period are almost always excluded — permanently.
Is pet insurance actually worth it?
Pet insurance is a financial hedge, not a savings plan. On average, pet owners pay more in premiums than they collect in claims — that's how insurance works. The value is protection against low-probability, high-cost events: cancer treatment ($5K–$20K), emergency surgery ($3K–$10K), or chronic disease management over years.
The math works in your favour if: you have a breed prone to expensive health issues (French Bulldogs, German Shepherds, Golden Retrievers), you'd pursue aggressive treatment for a serious illness, or you don't have $5K–$10K liquid savings to absorb an emergency. If you have a healthy mixed breed and a solid emergency fund, self-insuring (saving $50–$100/month yourself) can work just as well.
One clear rule: buy early. Pre-existing conditions are excluded by every provider. A knee injury at age 3 rules out cruciate coverage for life. Getting covered before problems emerge is the most important timing decision.
Looking for pet health calculators?
View all tools